West Side YMCA

7.1 · 3,531 reviews · New York City, USA

The latest recorded price at West Side YMCA in New York City was $96/night — above the typical historical price of $86/night. Common origins among historical guest samples include United States (34%), England (7%), France (7%).

What reviewers say

18 written reviews · past 24 months

Travelers consistently praise the property's prime location near Central Park and subway stations, as well as the helpfulness of the staff. However, opinions on the facility's condition are sharply divided, with many guests reporting severe issues regarding cleanliness, outdated institutional aesthetics, and uncomfortable sleeping conditions.

What reviewers liked

  • The hotel is highly valued for its excellent location, situated directly across from Central Park and near subway stations, making it a convenient and safe base for exploring the city.
  • Several guests highlighted the helpfulness and friendliness of the staff, noting that the team was great and contributed to a positive experience despite other shortcomings.
  • Access to YMCA facilities, including a gym and swimming pool, is a key benefit, and some travelers found basic amenities like WiFi and showers adequate for a short stay.

Downsides mentioned

  • Multiple reviews cited significant cleanliness issues, including thick dust, mold, stains, wet bathroom floors, and unpleasant sewer-like odors, leading to a perception of a dirty and poorly maintained environment.
  • Guests frequently complained about uncomfortable sleeping conditions, such as extremely thin pillows, wobbly bunk beds, and a lack of provided amenities like hair dryers or sufficient electrical outlets near the bed.
  • The property was described as noisy and uncomfortable, with issues including slamming doors, screeching air conditioning units, stuffy rooms, and a shortage of bathrooms during peak morning hours.

Reviewer age ranges

Reviewers shared age ranges in 18 of 18 reviews.

  • 18-24 0%
  • 25-30 16.7%
  • 31-40 22.2%
  • 41+ 61.1%
About these reviews

Review period · Nov 20, 2024–Nov 22, 2026

Fewer than 10 written reviews were available in the past 12 months, so this period includes the past 24 months.

Age ranges are shared by reviewers and appear in only some reviews. Percentages use only reviews with a known range and may not reflect all guests.

Read guest reviews(opens in a new tab)

The lowest listed private-room rate at West Side YMCA ranges from $82 to $387/night over the next 3 months. Based on current listings, January private rooms typically start around $95/night.

Price history

One private room · one night.

Loading stay prices…

Guest profile

Guest origins

Based on 1235 historical guest samples; not current bookings.

  • 🇺🇸 United States (33.6%)
    415
  • 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 England (7.3%)
    90
  • 🇫🇷 France (7.1%)
    88
  • 🇲🇽 Mexico (4.7%)
    58
  • 🇪🇸 Spain (4.3%)
    53
  • 🇦🇷 Argentina (4.2%)
    52

Other guests checking in

Next 14 check-in dates.

7 4 0
Nov 22Nov 28Dec 5
Other guests checking in by check-in date
Check-in dateOther guests checking in
6
5
3
3
3
3
5
7
6
5
3
4
3
3
Price alerts

Price alerts are not available for this stay yet.