Not Your Average Hotel

8.9 · 978 reviews · Key West, USA

The latest recorded price at Not Your Average Hotel in Key West was $250/night — near the typical historical price of $250/night. Common origins among historical guest samples include United States (53%), France (11%), England (9%).

What reviewers say

20 written reviews · past 24 months

Guests report a stark divide between praise for the hostel's prime Key West location, extensive pool facilities, and clean rooms, and severe complaints about rude staff, safety hazards, and hygiene issues. While some enjoyed a relaxing stay, others described dangerous conditions and aggressive behavior that led to negative experiences.

What reviewers liked

  • Guests highlight the clean and comfortable rooms, excellent and plentiful breakfast options, and the convenience of the location with nearby activities and parking.
  • Guests appreciated the prime location in Key West and the extensive pool area, which featured multiple pools, hot tubs, umbrellas, and lawn chairs for relaxation.
  • The hostel is praised for its great location in Key West, well-maintained grounds, and a lovely wraparound porch, with staff noted for being friendly and accommodating early check-ins.

Downsides mentioned

  • Multiple reviews cited extremely rude and aggressive staff behavior, including disputes over fees, refusal to assist guests, and calling police on guests who raised safety concerns.
  • Guests reported serious hygiene and safety issues, including black mold in the water system, a hole in the floor, and being placed in rooms with dangerous or unstable other guests.

Reviewer age ranges

Reviewers shared age ranges in 20 of 20 reviews.

  • 18-24 10%
  • 25-30 20%
  • 31-40 35%
  • 41+ 35%
About these reviews

Review period · Nov 19, 2024–Nov 22, 2026

Fewer than 10 written reviews were available in the past 12 months, so this period includes the past 24 months.

Age ranges are shared by reviewers and appear in only some reviews. Percentages use only reviews with a known range and may not reflect all guests.

Read guest reviews(opens in a new tab)

The lowest listed dorm-bed rate at Not Your Average Hotel is around $250/night over the next 1 day.

Price history

One dorm bed · one night.

Loading stay prices…

Guest profile

Guest origins

Based on 242 historical guest samples; not current bookings.

  • 🇺🇸 United States (52.5%)
    127
  • 🇫🇷 France (10.7%)
    26
  • 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 England (8.7%)
    21
  • 🇮🇹 Italy (5.4%)
    13
  • 🇩🇪 Germany (5.4%)
    13
  • 🇮🇳 India (3.3%)
    8

Other guests checking in

Next 14 check-in dates.

1 0
Dec 25Dec 27Dec 31
Other guests checking in by check-in date
Check-in dateOther guests checking in
No data
No data
1
No data
No data
Price alerts

Price alerts are not available for this stay yet.